Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jerry Myers's avatar

Our educational system is pushing college for all because college grads earn more than high school grads according to the statistics they use. What they leave out is that those that go into the trades often earn more than the average college graduate.

Several years ago I was teaching at a high school that had a stellar auto mechanics program. If students went through the entire program, they could graduate with ASE certification in multiple areas of car repairs. I had a few students that went through the entire program and interned at a local auto dealership the summer before their senior year. They were hired as full time mechanics at some of our local dealerships and they were earning more than I was as a teacher with a Master's in biology.

The district canned the program because they decided to focus on preparing all grads for college.

Then they tell students to major in something they like. I have been at parent/teacher/counselor meetings where the student wants to become a doctor and everyone is encouraging the student to go for that goal. We are having the meeting because they have a 1.0 GPA or lower and are so credit deficient they will not graduate and really need to go into another program. In my area, there are many programs that allow students to earn a high school diploma and learn a trade at the same time. I have had a few students do that.

Two years ago, the local power company was installing new gas lines in my neighborhood. The gas was shut off for a few days. When they turned it back on, they had to inspect all homes that were affected for gas leaks and they lite the pilot lights. The person that came to our door recognized my wife and I immediately. It took us a while to place where we knew him from. He had taken his freshmen year science from me (my first year teaching) and then had to repeat it because he failed it. He had my wife the second time.

He had many issues. What he remembered that we had both encouraged him to find a trade he would enjoy doing. He hated school and he was struggling academically. He finally went to an alternative school. While there he decided to enter a training program sponsored by or local power and gas company. He started from the bottom and worked his way up and is now a mid-level supervisor. He married and had three children. He said he ended up with the life he wanted because he took our advice and found an alternative program that let him earn his HS diploma and learn a trade. He still loves what he is doing.

When I graduated high school, I followed my heart and earned a Biology degree. I had an opportunity to earn a graduate degree in biochemistry but it was not what I was interested in. I went on to earn a graduate degree in Ecology and then went on for a Ph.D in entomology. During the time I was earning my Ph.D, I realized that there were very few job opportunities for me. Ph.Ds in the biological sciences were a dime a dozen. The one job I was working towards because the person at the research station was retiring soon, dried up when funding for it was cut upon his retirement.

I eventually became a high school biology teacher. It let me earn a decent living and have time to spend with my son. We travelled for 6 weeks every summer. Teaching has its problems that have gotten worse over time. There was a period where I hated it because I was at a school where the students ran everything and the administration would blame teachers for student misbehaviors. I was able to change schools and I know teach at a well run school that most students want to be at. Politically though, things reached a point that I can no longer teach to the high standards I want to teach at. I am retiring a year before I had planned.

Not a problem, we are moving out of CA and moving closer to our son and his family in a red state. I will find a job so I can remain busy and productive (it will not be in education).

The reason for my telling this story is that shortly after high school graduation, I had an opportunity to become an electrician. My grandfather was an electrician and he would pay my way to to through an apprentice program. I decided to do as my teachers had been telling me and go to college. This was 1980. It was the worst decision I made.

When my wife and I bought our fixer-upper house, it needed major electrical work. I went to the local library to learn all I could about electrical work. I purchased a book on the Electrical code.

It took 4 months of hard work during a hot summer, but I enjoyed doing it and my work passed inspection. I have since helped a few others do the electrical work that was needed on their homes and my work always passes inspection.

This is why I tell my students that they really should consider a trade. I wish someone had encouraged me to do that as a high school graduate.

This 27 year old does not have to remain a loser. He first has to accept that his sociology degree is useless. It will only lead to low paying jobs that suck. He may need to move to access a better job market. He should strongly consider the trades. In my area, many contractors are willing to higher someone who does not have the skills but has a strong work ethic. They will sponsor them to go to. a trade school and in exchange, they will work for him for 5 years.

He has his whole life ahead of him and he has earned an education about the real world that he can use to not repeat those same mistakes.

Frank Lee's avatar

Bingo.

That 27 year old "loser" needs to ask himself why he does not consider learning a trade and moving to where there are jobs. There are 500,000 unfilled manufacturing jobs in the US. There are about 1 million unfilled jobs in the trades. With more illegal immigrant deportation that will increase.

A sociology degree isn't a job skill.

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?