Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frank Lee's avatar

"Most of us chase status to some degree, but the more your life revolves around it, the more unhappy you’re likely to be."

I don't think this quite right. I think all of us crave a position of status hierarcy relative to our expectations within our peer group. I think where unhappiness happens is the feeling of not having achieved expected status. And the Hedonic Treadmill theory - basically that we always progress upward in our expectations... we always want more (why the euphoria after the promotion or sale or win... is replaced by the motivation for the next one). This constant need for more is our blessing and curse. It drives exploration, invention and progress. But it also drives terrible selfish behavior and envy.

But you can see how collectivism can derive more relative happiness, because there will be less competition for status in the peer group. Misery loves company. In a free market democracy, merit keeps increasing and the bar for high status keeps rising... as do the individual expectations. It gets harder to get noticed, and it causes people to act out. It flows destuctive.

A productive US happiness machine requires a lot of economic opportunity and growth. We had it. But it is the combination of our past success, our more recent decline and our stuffing of so many into the expectation for upper class status, that has resulted in the drop in happiness... and people acting out.

Many people can find happiness in a simple life, but these are people generally not expecting more. Almost everyone not having achieved some level of expected peer group status will be unhappy. Yes, contributing to society can help with life statisfaction, but for most people, generally not if it does not add perceived peer status.

Q Carbonero's avatar

Thanks, John. Nice to get a heart on...

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?